Encore: 'Only Murders in the Building': Steve Martin on creating Hulu's hit comedy

Written by Anna Buss, produced by Joshua Farnham

'Only Murders in the Building' season 3 trailer. Courtesy of Hulu via YouTube.

Hulu’s original series Only Murders in the Building is back for its third season. The show has received 11 Emmy nominations for season two, including Outstanding Comedy Series, Outstanding Writing For A Comedy Series, and Martin Short landing his second straight nomination for Lead Actor In A Comedy. Its huge success in its first season led to three Emmys statues.

Season three of the comedic murder-mystery series, continues to tell the saga of three neighbors – Charles-Haden Savage (Steve Martin), a lonely one-time TV star; Oliver Putnam (Short), a faded broadway director; and Mabel Mora (Selena Gomez), who’s living in her wealthy aunt’s apartment. The trio is entangled in another murder-investigation in their exclusive Upper West side building. Added to the cast are obnoxious actor Ben Glenroy (Paul Rudd) and a failed-aging actress Loretta Durkin (Meryl Streep). 

The shows’ co-creators Martin and John Hoffman explain how they met and what it took to get this idea from paper onto the screen.

Sharing the “spark of an idea”

Martin had been invited to one of talent manager’s Sandy Gallin’s showbiz parties in New York. There, he recalls seeing a lot of actors, including three older ones, when Gallin suggested he should write something for them. 

“I thought, ‘That's a good idea: three older guys who live in a building and solve murders because they don't have anything else to do,’” Martin recalls. His premise was: “They're too tired to go downtown to investigate things, so they limit it to only murderers in the building, so they could just stay home to solve the crime.” 

From that idea, Martin was introduced to John Hoffman and the two created Only Murders in the Building

After Martin came up with the concept for the show, in another show biz moment, his agent, Danny Greenberg, set up a lunch-meeting with Dan Fogelman, the creator of the acclaimed television comedy-drama This Is Us

Martin wasn’t thrilled with the plan at first, thinking this was one of those gatherings where “everybody’s fascinated with each other,” and as soon as it is over, “everybody is bored and the fascination is over, and nothing ever happens.”

They met, and as they were getting the check, Martin shared his idea about three older men solving crimes in their building. “As it was coming out of my mouth, we all kind of realized, ‘This isn't a bad idea!,’” he recalls, and then, “it just went on like a high-speed train.” 

Fogelman became one of the show’s executive producers along with Jess Rosenthal, who then connected Hoffman to Martin. “You definitely don't say no to that meeting,” says Hoffman, who came onboard as a co-creator of the show. 

Before they were teamed up, Hoffman recalls parking his car when he received an email about Martin’s idea. He sat in his car and immediately “started typing things about pre-war apartment buildings and my love for them in New York City,” he says. “And I started to think about true crime podcasting, and how to make this idea sing in a modern way…and I thought about Ruth Gordon and Rosemary's Baby

Fogelman, Rosenthal, Martin and Hoffman had a “meeting of the minds” and began a conversation of the show’s first episode.  

“I leaned heavily into Steve Martin at the very beginning,” to write that first episode, says co-creator John Hoffman. Selena Gomez (left), Martin Short and Steve Martin film a scene of Only Murders in the Building in New York on December 9, 2021. Photo by Jose Perez/INSTARimages/Cover Images via REUTERS 

Drawing from personal experiences

To help inform the show, writer and co-creator Hoffman leaned into a personal “true crime” story. He had a close childhood friend who, as an adult, was found shot to death. Hoffman says he experienced a “profound drive to understand” what happened to his friend whom he had lost touch with years earlier. “I could not fathom that as being the case. I knew he could never shoot anyone,” he says. 

He went to Wisconsin to follow the investigation, and got to know his friend’s ex-wife and children, and met with a local reporter and neighbors next to the house where his friend died. “I just got obsessed with it, and I couldn't shake it emotionally,” he recalls. By the end of the year, the police report concluded that his friend had been murdered. 

Also providing invaluable input to the series was Martin, who is a true crime aficionado. Hoffman remembers visiting Martin’s apartment in New York. There, Martin pulled him over to his kitchen to look across the courtyard to another window with a light on. Martin then asks him if could see the activity in the window across from them, and Hoffman answered, “Yeah, there's a man and his daughter, and they're having a little cracker?” And Martin said, “Yeah, that's not happening in that apartment. That's happening in the apartment underneath us. And that's the reflection on that window.’”

From there, Martin took Hoffman on a tour of his apartment building, walking him “through the intricacies that he had discovered and was interested in,” Hoffman says. “I leaned heavily into Steve Martin at the very beginning,” to write that first episode.  

Pitching the show to Hulu

Martin and his co-creators took the show to Hulu without shopping it elsewhere.  Fogelman, their executive producer, who has an overall deal with Disney’s 20th Century Television, identified the streaming service as the platform for the show. Hoffman recalls that they had a script with a general arc of the first ten episodes and an ending, and that Dana Walden, the Chairman of Disney General Entertainment Content, was there to hear Martin’s proposal. 

One of the questions Martin was asked was if the show was comedy or drama. “In dramas, people walk slow. And in comedies, people walk fast. In this show, people walk fast,” he responded.  

The pitch worked, and a couple of hours later, Walden called Fogelman saying they would pick up ten episodes. 

Getting the show off paper during the pandemic

Though Martin has watched a lot of mysteries, writing one was a complicated task. He says he feels lucky though that they have a team of writers “to keep the story going.”

Because pre-production started during the pandemic, they assembled a team of writers on Zoom, which proved to be challenging. Hoffman explains that breaking up ten episodes of “a very intricate mystery,” required whiteboards, which wasn’t possible to do virtually. They also found it difficult to keep the focus alive, even when Martin, Short and Gomez joined Zoom to read, to make sure that “they were clear, and that the mystery was compelling enough to have them on the edge of their seat not knowing which way it was going.” 

“I can't even imagine the show without [Selena Gomez] now,” says Steve Martin, co-creator of the show. “Marty [Short] and I, even when no one's listening, say how great she is.” Martin Short (L) Selena Gomez and Steve Martin film a scene at the Only Murders in The Building set in Uptown, Manhattan on March 21, 2023. Photo by Jose Perez/INSTARimages.com/Cover Images via REUTERS

Adding Selena Gomez to the cast

The initial idea for the show was to have three old men protagonists. Martin, however, already expected the studio to say they wanted a young person in the mix. Fogelman suggested Selena Gomez for the third role, which Martin was a little skeptical at first because he didn’t know much about her.

“I looked her up when they first mentioned her name,” Martin says. “She's had a whole career that I wouldn’t know about, and she had done as many movies as I had. So she's a pro.” 

Three weeks before they started shooting in New York City, Gomez joined Martin and Short for a reading of the show’s first episode on Zoom. “We heard the three of them for the first time together and our phones just lit up afterwards, and we were all buzzing,” recalls Hoffman. “Steve and Marty were both in my ear going, ‘She was unbelievable.’” 

Now, Martin says he can’t imagine anyone else replacing Gomez. “We didn't realize how much Selena was going to contribute… because she brings us down to Earth, our characters, and [she] also has the right amount of snide. It just turned out to be perfect for us.”

“I have no desire to quit!” 

Martin, who’s starring in a scripted TV series for the first time, loves being on show. 

“I have no desire to quit,” he states. “I love working with friends that way. I love that it's being well-received. It's intriguing. It's like Steven Spielberg says, ‘I just make movies I want to see,’ and you're not second guessing yourself because I feel this is a show I'd like to watch.” 

In the series, Charles-Haden Savage’s TV character Brazzos (played by Martin), sings the novelty song “Angel in Flip-Flops,” which Martin co-wrote and performed for the show.  



Kim Masters


Joshua Farnham