Listen Live
Donate
 on air
    Schedule

    KCRW

    Read & Explore

    • News
    • Entertainment
    • Food
    • Culture
    • Events

    Listen

    • Live Radio
    • Music
    • Podcasts
    • Full Schedule

    Information

    • About
    • Careers
    • Help / FAQ
    • Newsletters
    • Contact

    Support

    • Become a Member
    • Become a VIP
    • Ways to Give
    • Shop
    • Member Perks

    Become a Member

    Donate to KCRW to support this cultural hub for music discovery, in-depth journalism, community storytelling, and free events. You'll become a KCRW Member and get a year of exclusive benefits.

    DonateGive Monthly

    Copyright 2026 KCRW. All rights reserved.

    Report a Bug|Privacy Policy|Terms of Service|
    Cookie Policy
    |FCC Public Files|

    Back to Good Food

    Good Food

    Real versus Imitation Vanilla Extract

    Jack Bishop is the Executive Editor of Cook's Illustrated and America's Test Kitchen, which recently did an extensive taste test between imitation and pure vanilla extract.  McCormick's Pure Vanilla Extract was declared the winner.

    • rss
    • apple-podcasts
    • spotify
    • Share
    By Evan Kleiman • May 12, 2014 • 1 min read

    Jack Bishop is the Executive Editor of Cook's Illustrated and America's Test Kitchen, which recently did an extensive taste test between imitation and pure vanilla extract. McCormick's Pure Vanilla Extract was declared the winner.

    Vanilla Cake

    2 1/2 cups flour

    1 Tablespoon baking powder

    1 tsp salt

    1 cup butter, softened

    1 1/2 cups granulated sugar

    4 tsp vanilla extract

    4 eggs

    3/4 cup milk

    Vanilla Buttercream Frosting

    1 cup butter, softened

    2 tsp vanilla extract

    16 ozs confectioners' sugar

    2 Tablespoons milk

    Music break: Fathead by Lee Morgan

    The full episode

    7 of 8
    Irish Pubs; Obama Foodorama; Clam Invasion; Animal Dudes;
    1. 0:00Market Report
    2. 7:00Irish Pub Crawl
    3. 14:00The Animal Dudes
    4. 21:00Food Fraud
    5. 21:00Dining in Santa Barbara and Ventura Counties
    6. 35:00Asian Clams Invade Lake Tahoe
    7. 42:00Real versus Imitation Vanilla ExtractYou’re reading this
    8. 49:00Obama Foodorama
    • https://images.ctfassets.net/2658fe8gbo8o/AvYox6VuEgcxpd20Xo9d3/769bca4fbf97bf022190f4813812c1e2/new-default.jpg?h=250

      Evan Kleiman

      host 'Good Food'

    • https://images.ctfassets.net/2658fe8gbo8o/AvYox6VuEgcxpd20Xo9d3/769bca4fbf97bf022190f4813812c1e2/new-default.jpg?h=250

      Bob Carlson

      host and producer, 'UnFictional'

    • https://images.ctfassets.net/2658fe8gbo8o/AvYox6VuEgcxpd20Xo9d3/769bca4fbf97bf022190f4813812c1e2/new-default.jpg?h=250

      Jennifer Ferro

      Jennifer Ferro, President, KCRW, Los Angeles

    • KCRW placeholder

      Thea Chaloner

      Supervising Producer, Good Food

      CultureFood & Drink

    The full episode

    7 of 8
    Irish Pubs; Obama Foodorama; Clam Invasion; Animal Dudes;
    1. 0:00Market Report
    2. 7:00Irish Pub Crawl
    3. 14:00The Animal Dudes
    4. 21:00Food Fraud
    5. 21:00Dining in Santa Barbara and Ventura Counties
    6. 35:00Asian Clams Invade Lake Tahoe
    7. 42:00Real versus Imitation Vanilla ExtractYou’re reading this
    8. 49:00Obama Foodorama
    Back to Good Food