Has Guantanamo Bay Been Holding the Wrong Men?

Hosted by

The Bush Administration calls prisoners at Guantánamo Bay "the worst of the worst," but one of its own top officials says at least a third never belonged there. The US Supreme Court says they have the right to challenge their detention, but dissenting Justice Scalia warns that could lead to Americans being killed. Out of 770 Guantánamo detainees almost 500 have been released; 60 more have been cleared. Do they pose a danger? We hear about the most extensive investigation so far into who they are and how they got to Guantánamo Bay.


Tom Lasseter - Reporter, McClatchy Newspapers, Murat Kurnaz - former Guantanamo detainee, Reuel Marc Gerecht - Foundation for Defense of Democracies - @followFDD, Baher Azmy - Center for Constitutional Rights - @theCCR

Warren Olney

Christian Bordal, Dan Konecky, Frances Anderton