OC Silverado Fire: A test of whether native plant restoration methods work

On a recent warm day, Irvine Ranch Conservancy CEO Michael O’Connell walked along Agua Chinon Canyon, in the hills east of Irvine, surveying the damage from October’s Silverado Fire.

O’Connell stooped down to look at some plants. “Look at this. These are green and didn’t get burned. And then five feet away, it was almost a complete burn.”

Crews and volunteers with the Irvine Ranch Conservancy, which oversees this public land, had spent the last five years restoring this canyon within Limestone Canyon Regional Park back to its native state, with lush vegetation around the creek.

This watershed is fairly dry this time of year, but it is the headwaters of San Diego Creek, which empties into Upper Newport Bay, said O’Connell.

The conservancy had just finished restoring it when the Silverado Fire hit, burning in much of the same footprint as the destructive Santiago Fire did in 2007. That earlier fire churned through 28,445 acres, destroying 16 homes. It burned hot, leaving a barren moonscape behind. The Silverado Fire has some areas like that, but others still have green signs of life.

“The fire came through relatively quickly,” O’Connell said. “And so it left some refugia of unburned habitat, which is really important long term because it’s a refuge for wildlife, and it’s also a refuge for plants that might have been burned in some other areas.”

O’Connell said the biggest problem isn’t that a fire took out their restoration area.

“These systems are essentially evolved with fire. Our biggest problem is that they evolved with fire that comes back about every 50 to 150 years,” O’Connell said. “This is the third time that these lands have burned in the last 23 years. That is 90% too often. And so what happens is they don’t come back as well the more you burn them over and over and over again.”

He pointed out that the 2007 Santiago Fire wiped out 12% of the area’s mature oak trees. A generation of oaks is about a century. So O’Connell said if you burn every seven years, you lose 12% of your population every seven years, which means you lose the entire native oak woodland in a generation.

“The resilience of these habitats is very much like your immune system,” O’Connell said. “If you get sick and you recover, you’ll be okay. And then if you get sick again too soon, you’ll start to get sicker. And then if you get sick again, then it’s really hard to recover. And essentially, what’s going on in these systems with too much fire is that they’re getting sicker. And so we’re trying now to figure out what is it that we can do to try and keep them healthy and resilient over time.”

O’Connell said they will spend the next three to five years monitoring the area to see which native plants rebound and which might need help. They are also using trail cameras to help track wildlife in the area. Some of those cameras may have even captured the fire coming through. They are still gathering the data.

But before they could do anything, a second fire, the Bond Fire, burned near the same area again this month. It made it to near the top of the canyon, but luckily, did not burn through again.

Still, instead of viewing the destruction of newly restored canyon land along a creek from the Silverado Fire as a failure, O’Connell said there is a silver lining.

Except the seed farm did not escape the Silverado Fire either. Embers caught the seed farm on fire, too, burning plants and several buildings. They lost some of their buckwheat crop, along with their white sage crop.

They will have to rebuild a few lost buildings, but O’Connell is still hopeful. As he walked back up the canyon to return to his car, he pointed to a cactus that looked like it melted in the fire.

This part of Limestone Canyon Regional Park remains closed to the public because of the fire, but O’Connell hopes that in the near future, it will reopen with a renewed native habitat that’s more fire resilient.